Lead Lamp Media
  • Services
    • Social Media Marketing
    • Video Production
    • Podcast Production
    • Custom Websites
    • Graphic Design
    • SEO
    • Branding
    • Paid Ads
    • Data & Analytics
  • Portfolio
  • About
    • Lead Lamp Podcast
    • Story
    • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
    Contacts

    Address:

    50 Utley Dr, Camp Hill, PA 17011

    Phone:

    +1 717 288 6116

    Email:

    info@leadlamps.com
    Instagram
    TikTok
    Facebook
    Youtube
    LinkedIn
    Get in Touch

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lead Lamp Media
  • Services
    • Social Media Marketing
    • Video Production
    • Podcast Production
    • Custom Websites
    • Graphic Design
    • SEO
    • Branding
    • Paid Ads
    • Data & Analytics
  • Portfolio
  • About
    • Lead Lamp Podcast
    • Story
    • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
    Contacts

    Address:

    50 Utley Dr, Camp Hill, PA 17011

    Phone:

    +1 717 288 6116

    Email:

    info@leadlamps.com
    Instagram
    TikTok
    Facebook
    Youtube
    LinkedIn
    Get in Touch

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Lead Lamp Media
  • Services
    • Social Media Marketing
    • Video Production
    • Podcast Production
    • Custom Websites
    • Graphic Design
    • SEO
    • Branding
    • Paid Ads
    • Data & Analytics
  • Portfolio
  • About
    • Lead Lamp Podcast
    • Story
    • Our Team
  • Resources
  • Contact
    Contacts

    Address:

    50 Utley Dr, Camp Hill, PA 17011

    Phone:

    +1 717 288 6116

    Email:

    info@leadlamps.com
    Instagram
    TikTok
    Facebook
    Youtube
    LinkedIn
    Get in Touch

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Contacts

Address:

27 Division St, New York, NY 10002, USA

Phone:

+1 800 123 456 789

Email:

poity@mail.com

Subscribe

Our expertise, as well as our passion for web design, sets us apart from other agencies.

Instagram
Twitter
LinkedIn

Partners

clients-4
clients-3
clients-2
clients-5
clients-6

Let`s get started!

Click here
Instagram
YouTube
Facebook
LinkedIn
coffee Tag
HomePosts Tagged "coffee"

Tag: coffee

A photo of Stavros Katsifis, co-owner of Silver Side Cafe and Creamery on the Lead Lamp Podcast
PodcastOctober 8, 2026By Tyler Dolbin

Lead Lamp Podcast Ep. 81: Stavros Katsifis, co-owner of Silver Side Cafe and Creamery

From Historic Landmark to Community Gathering Spot: How Silver Side Cafe & Creamery Saved a 1950s Diner

When you walk into Silver Side Cafe & Creamery in Mechanicsburg, you’re stepping into more than just a coffee shop or ice cream parlor. You’re walking into a piece of Central Pennsylvania history that was literally moved to make room for the future. And yes, that’s exactly as dramatic as it sounds.

The story of Silver Side starts with a vision that’s been decades in the making. Stavros Katsifis and his family didn’t just open another cafe. They saved a 1950s architectural gem from disappearing altogether—and transformed it into what’s become one of the most unique gathering spots in Silver Spring Township.

The Beginning: A Father’s Dream for the Community

The idea for Silver Side didn’t start with Stavros. It started with his dad, Bill Katsifis, who had a simple observation about their Silver Spring Township neighborhood. Even though the area had plenty of businesses, something was missing.

“There’s not really a good place near where we live for ice cream,” Bill had been saying for years. It wasn’t a complaint. It was an opportunity waiting to happen.

Stavros grew up in the area, just two miles from where the shop is today. He attended Cumberland Valley High School and spent his formative years watching his father operate a diner in Harrisburg. But his father’s dream about creating a dedicated destination for ice cream and coffee never went away.

As the family started exploring what they could actually build, they realized something important. Coffee shops and ice cream shops serve similar roles in their communities. They’re gathering places. They’re where people linger, connect, and feel welcomed. So why not combine them?

“I think the connection to coffee and the environment that a coffee shop has in the community is very similar to what an ice cream shop has,” Stavros explains. What started as his father’s simple ice cream idea evolved into something bigger: a dual-purpose destination that could serve both morning coffee crowds and evening dessert seekers.

The Building: A Historic O’Mahony Diner

Here’s where the story gets really interesting. The building itself is a 1950s O’Mahony diner—and these aren’t just any diners. O’Mahonys are considered the Cadillac of diner construction, built in the 1940s and 1950s by a New Jersey manufacturer. They were prefabricated, assembled like train cars, and literally delivered on trucks to their destinations.

This particular diner is even more special. It’s an L-shaped model with two diner “cars” connected together. When you understand diner history, you realize these buildings are genuinely historic. They’re pieces of American Americana, the kind of classic architecture that people expect to see on Route 66, not necessarily in Central PA.

The diner’s journey is just as fascinating as its construction. It originally operated as Ray’s Diner in Harrisburg, where it survived the devastating Agnes flood of 1972—barely. The building was flooded up to its windows, which basically destroyed the business at the time. But decades later, in the 1980s, Stavros Sr. and his father discovered this abandoned gem and purchased it.

They rebuilt it and operated it as a diner for many years. But the building’s story wasn’t finished yet.

Facing Eminent Domain: A Tough Choice

Around 2019 or 2020, the family faced a challenge they weren’t expecting. The Pennsylvania Department of Transportation approached them with news that hit hard: the state was planning a highway construction project that would require taking the property.

Eminent domain isn’t something you can fight very effectively. “Your fate is almost sealed,” Stavros says, reflecting on that moment. The family had no idea what their options were or what would happen to the building they’d invested so much time and energy into preserving.

But here’s where things took a turn for the better. The family learned that their diner building had been officially designated as a historic structure. That designation meant it couldn’t just be demolished like a regular building. It had to be preserved or relocated.

Instead of letting the building be stored away or sold off to an uncertain future, the family made a bold decision: they’d move it. And not just anywhere—they’d move it to a new location where they could finally build the cafe and creamery that had been part of their vision all along.

The Engineering Feat: Moving an Entire Diner

Moving a 1950s diner isn’t something you just decide to do on a whim. It requires specialized equipment, permits, expertise, and honestly, a lot of nerve. But the Katsifis family found companies that specialize in exactly this kind of work.

The process was mind-boggling. Workers had to carefully separate the two diner cars at their natural seam—the exact place where they’d originally been connected. They placed hydraulic trailers underneath each section, using specialized engineering to lift these historic structures completely off the ground.

Once secured to the trailers, the diner sections were literally driven to their new location. “It was such a crazy feat of engineering,” Stavros recalls, noting that the family documented the whole thing with photos and videos.

The state and township actually worked with the family to make this happen faster than normal. While the full construction permits and building process would take time, they allowed the diner to be moved temporarily as “storage” while they planned the permanent installation. “Pretty much,” Stavros explains, they were buying time for a bigger problem: getting the building out before the highway project took over.

Building Something New While Honoring the Past

Once the diner was safely in its new location in Silver Spring Township, the real work began. The family had this historic building—with all its original metal fixtures and 75-80 years of character—and they needed to transform it into a modern cafe and creamery.

Their approach was thoughtful. They wanted to keep the diner’s charm and retro feeling but update it for contemporary use. They removed some of the original booths to open up space, though they kept enough to maintain that classic diner aesthetic. They added a substantial outdoor deck and seating area, which was crucial to their vision.

“We kind of blended the two,” Stavros says about mixing old and new. “Everything we did is like we’re putting two opposites together. Cold ice cream, hot coffee. Inside, outside space. Old building, new everything else.”

The property itself is perfect for this dual-use business. It’s located on Carlisle Pike (highly visible), but set back about an acre from the road. That means customers get the marketing advantage of a main-road location without the noise of constant traffic. The outdoor space is genuinely peaceful, with fire pits for cooler evenings.

In-House Ice Cream and Locally Roasted Coffee

What Stavros and his team do inside Silver Side matters just as much as the building they do it in. They’re not buying pre-made ice cream from a distributor. They’re making it in-house, which is a significant commitment to quality.

“We’re controlling it,” Stavros explains. “We know where it is, where it’s from. And we kind of have creative control over the end product.”

The coffee side is equally committed to local sourcing. They partner with a local roaster in Lemoyne, and they’re working on developing their own house-made syrups for both the coffee and ice cream sides.

This dual focus on quality creates unexpected synergies. The flavors they develop for ice cream can inform their coffee syrups, and vice versa. They’re complementary in ways the family never anticipated when they started. The mint-chocolate Oreo ice cream they introduced recently? It became one of their fastest sellers, surprising even Stavros himself.

Creating a “Third Place” for the Community

Beyond the products, Silver Side’s real mission is about creating what Stavros calls a “third place.” Most people have home and work. But what about that third space where people can feel comfortable, belong, and connect with their community?

For many people, that’s disappearing. But Silver Side is intentionally trying to fill that gap. They’re hosting events like yoga sessions in the courtyard, National Ice Cream Day celebrations with cornhole and frisbee, and they’re planning movie nights and live music performances.

There’s something special about what Silver Side is building. A gentleman in a wheelchair came in recently with what appeared to be his grandchildren. They encouraged him to play the jukebox—an original, working vintage jukebox that still takes quarters. He played an Elvis song, and Stavros watched as this man, who hadn’t been moving around much, started tapping his foot. “That’s what this is,” Stavros realized. Creating moments. Bridging generations. Making memories.

The Silver Side Experience

What makes Silver Side work isn’t just the ice cream or coffee. It’s the intentional design of the space and the community focus behind it. The original diner exterior creates instant nostalgia for people who remember real diners. For younger visitors who’ve never experienced that era, it’s creating entirely new memories.

Whether you’re coming for a morning coffee meeting, an afternoon ice cream run, a fire pit evening, or one of their community events, Silver Side offers something increasingly rare: a welcoming, authentic space designed for gathering and connection. It’s a reminder that sometimes the best business ideas aren’t about maximizing efficiency. They’re about maximizing meaning.

Visit Silver Side Cafe & Creamery

Located at 25 Waterford Drive, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050 (just past Cumberland Valley High School on Carlisle Pike), Silver Side Cafe & Creamery offers homemade ice cream, locally roasted coffee, and a space designed for your community.

Keep up with their latest flavors, events, and announcements on Instagram (@silversidecafecreamery) and Facebook (Silver Side Cafe and Creamery), or visit their website at silversidepa.com.

FAQ

What makes Silver Side’s ice cream special?
Silver Side makes all their ice cream in-house rather than buying from distributors. This allows them to control quality, experiment with unique flavors, and create products that complement their coffee offerings.

Is Silver Side open year-round?
Yes, Silver Side operates year-round. While many people associate ice cream with summer, they serve both coffee and ice cream throughout the year, with outdoor fire pits available during cooler months.

What’s the story behind the historic diner building?
The building is a 1950s O’Mahony diner that was originally operated as Ray’s Diner in Harrisburg. After the family purchased it in the 1980s, a highway construction project required them to move it. Rather than let the historic structure be demolished, they relocated it to its current Mechanicsburg location.

Does Silver Side host events?
Yes. They regularly host community events including yoga sessions, National Ice Cream Day celebrations, and are planning movie nights and live music performances. They also have outdoor space available for customers to gather.

Where is Silver Side located and how do I find them?
Silver Side is located at 25 Waterford Drive, Mechanicsburg, PA 17050, just past Cumberland Valley High School on Carlisle Pike. You can find them on Instagram, Facebook, or visit silversidepa.com for hours and more information.

What coffee does Silver Side use?
Silver Side partners with a locally-roasted coffee from Lemoyne and develops their own house-made syrups to complement both their coffee and ice cream offerings.

What’s the vibe at Silver Side?
Silver Side intentionally designs itself as a “third place”—a welcoming community space beyond home and work. The vintage diner creates nostalgia for some while introducing younger guests to classic Americana. The emphasis is on connection and gathering as much as on the products they serve.

Would you or someone you know like to be a guest on the Lead Lamp Podcast? Contact us to share your Central PA business story.

Do you or your business need help with marketing & advertising? Contact Lead Lamp Media today to discuss how we can help grow your presence.

Read More

Light the Spark.
Lead the Market.

Turn your vision into videos, websites, or content that converts.

(717)288-6116
info@leadlamps.com
Instagram
TikTok
YouTube
Facebook
LinkedIn

Useful Links

Home
Services
Portfolio
About
Contact

Listen to our podcast

Grab your coffee, flip the switch, and join us as we brighten your week with stories that lead the way in innovation, creativity, and community impact.

Watch The Podcast
Listen To The Podcast

© 2026 Lead Lamp Media. All Rights Reserved

Camp Hill | Mechanicsburg | Carlisle | Harrisburg | Hershey | Lancaster | York  Dillsburg | Williamsport | Allentown